A reminder that procurement claims must be brought within time and by economic operators with the necessary standing


2nd October 2019

A national health trust (and incumbent provider of the services being procured) (“the Trust”) challenged a contracting authority’s contract award decision. The Trust had decided not to bid for the contract but sought an order to prohibit the authority from entering into the contract with the winning bidder.

The claims put forward by the Trust included that the authority had breached the principles of proportionality and transparency, and that it had accepted an abnormally low bid. The authority sought for the Trust’s application to be struck out.

The High Court agreed with the Trust and struck out the claim on the following basis:

  • the Trust was time-barred under Regulation 92 of the Public Contracts Regulations 2015 as amended (“PCR”) and there was no good reason to extend the deadline;
  • the Trust had interpreted the disclosure obligations on contracting authorities under Regulations 55 and 86 PCR too widely – the Trust was not entitled to receive certain information about the conduct of the procurement when it had decided not to participate.

The Court also commented that the Trust had not in any event shown that it had suffered loss or risked suffering loss in consequence of any breach of duty. It’s decision not to tender deprived it of the rights created by Regulation 86 PCR.

Royal Cornwall Hospitals NHS Trust v Cornwall Council [2019] EWHC 2211 (TCC)

Contact our public procurement team for specialist legal advice on procurement claims,

Enjoy That? You Might Like These:


articles

5 August - Alexander Shirtcliff
If you are seeking an injunction against Bitcoin or other crypto assets, here are our three key tips. Read More

articles

3 August - Tom Beard
The exercise of a contracting authority's discretion to exclude several bidders in a rail franchise procurement was proved to be lawful as we take a look at a recent judgment. Read More

articles

22 July - Nicola Diggle
The recent High Court judgment of Towergate Financial (Group) Ltd and other companies v Hopkinson and others [2020] EWHC 984 (Comm) warns of the importance of having clear and unambiguous... Read More