Dispute resolution

The dispute resolution group at Blake Morgan, with more than 120 fee earners, is one of 11 National Leaders outside London (Chambers and Partners 2016) in the UK, and in addition has a highly regarded London team that carries out the full spectrum of City work. We resolve disputes in the courts and in arbitration for international, national and regional clients by providing practical and commercially focused solutions. Our sizeable regional presence, coupled with our London offering, provides us with the strength and depth to act on the most complex and significant of contentious problems but at competitive rates.

Main areas of practice 

We have a large number of specialists, many of whom are regarded by the independent directories as leaders in their field, and provide a mediation service. We have experience in all types of commercial and contract disputes, with specialisms in the following areas:

Banking and finance disputes 
Employment disputes   Product liability
Business support and insolvency Franchising disputes  Professional negligence 
Civil fraud and asset recovery Intellectual property disputes
Property litigation
Commercial agents

International commercial disputes

Public law
Company disputes Judicial reviews Public procurement Litigation
Construction and engineering disputes Partnership disputes Social housing 
Corporate and shareholder disputes  Pensions disputes 

 

Will and inheritance disputes

Defamation and reputation management

Privy Council 

 
Please see a full list of links below in Related Expertise.

Clients 

We work with national and international corporations, government departments, regulators, financial institutions, individuals, partnerships and owner managed businesses. Clients for whom we have acted include:

Alcatel Principality Building Society Solicitors Regulatory Authority NHS England
AXA Insurance plc IBM Tinopolis plc Kerry Group
DHL NHS Shared Services Partnership University of South Wales  
  Personal Hygiene Services Ltd. Welsh Government  

Significant experience 

Examples of cases in which we have recently acted include:

  • Acting for the 7 Health Boards in Wales to successfully defeat a challenge to their interpretation of section 49 Health and Social Care Act 2001 brought by 11 care home providers, supported by 21 local authorities in Wales. The Court of Appeal agreed that Health Boards are responsible only for the cost of nursing care, rather than personal or social care which might, on occasions, be delivered by a Registered Nurse. The decision has saved the NHS in England and Wales an estimated £250 million per annum. R(Forge Care Homes) v Cardiff and Vale University Health Board [2016] EWCA Civ 26
  • Successfully acting for NHS England in the first case to consider the NHS (Competition, Procurement and Patient Choice) No 2 Regulations 2013. The case concerned an application for Judicial Review of a decision by NHS England not to contract with a provider for an interim period pending a national review and procurement of the service in question. Damages were also claimed under the Human Rights Act 1998. R (on the application of) v National Health Service Commissioning Board and another [2015] EWHC 3752
  • Acting for King Edward VI College in the Court of Appeal in successfully resisting a challenge by three teachers, sponsored by the NASUWT, who alleged that too much had been deducted from their pay  by way of strike pay.  The case involved a detailed consideration of the individual terms of employment [ as contained in “ the Red Book’] and the effect of the Apportionment Act  1870 on contracts of employment. Hartley & Others v King Edward VI College [2015] EWCA Civ 455
  • Acting for Peter Symonds College in its successful defence of a High Court claim, sponsored by the NUT, concerning the correct deduction from pay for strike action. Amey V Peter Symonds College [2013] EWHC 2788 
  • Acting for IBM United Kingdom Ltd in successfully defending a claim by the London Borough of Southwark concerning the supply and implementation of an MDM system, which Southwark alleged was not of satisfactory quality and unfit for purpose. Southwark London Borough Council v IBM Uk ltd [2011] EWHC 549 (TCC) QBD
  • Acting in a series of connected claims relating to a substantial tax fraud. The cases have required UK freezing injunctions and protective proceedings awards. To date over £8m has been recovered from banks in the UK and in Curacao in the Caribbean. 
  • Acting for a US-based investment fund on the purchase of subordinated loan notes in a foreign retail bank for in excess of 25 million euros. Advising the investment group on claims against the directors and officers of the bank for misrepresentation and breach of statutory duty and claims against the auditors for negligent misstatement
  • Acting for an Eire Partnership and Isle of Man companies in a claim for 43 million Euros against multiple defendants in the UK and elsewhere, including multi- jurisdictional proceedings, obtaining a worldwide freezing order and advising on the validity of a suite of detailed loan documentation.
  • Advising an NHS CCG on a complex dispute with a national private health company relating to a £450m contract for community health services.
  • Advising a regional police authority on a high value procurement and contractual dispute (that has national implications) with one of the leading mobile telephone companies.
  • Acting for a supplier in a substantial claim for breach of contract against an agro-industrial company operating in France and the rest of Europe.
  • Acting for the Representative Beneficiary in a Beddoe application concerning a professional negligence claim against solicitors relating to equalisation advice.
  • Acting for a software house in relation to the development of bespoke facilities management software and defending a claim by the end user that the software did not have the requisite functionality, contained several "showstopper" bugs and that the code was late in delivery.
  • Acting in a number of multi-party product liability disputes, all concerning the supply of defective goods which then contaminated other products in the supply chain.

Regional contacts;

Chris Potts- Thames Valley

Sarah Rees- London

 Allan Wilson - Wales

Susie Dryden- South Coast 

Related expertise

Main contacts

Related Knowledge & Resources

Blake Morgan litigation expert awarded Professional of the Year at the Venus Awards

Press Release

Blake Morgan Partner and Divisional Director of Litigation and Dispute Resolution, Alison McClure, has been awarded the title of 'Professional of the Year' at the prestigious Venus Awards.

Judgment from the Supreme Court in Welsh Care Home Sector case

News

Our team represented a client in the Supreme Court where a judgment was handed down.

Blake Morgan strengthens Commercial Litigation team

Press Release

Blake Morgan has made two key appointments to build on the success of its London-based commercial litigation practice.

Is your IPTV box "legit"?

A pub landlord was being sued by Football Association Premier League Limited for copyright infringement for using a IPTV box. Here is what happened next.

The dangers of using false accreditations

The recent case of National Guild of Removers and Storers Ltd v Bee Moved Ltd demonstrates the dangers of falsely claiming accreditation with an association.

Night club owner faces prison sentence due to ongoing Copyright Infringement

A night club owner has been sentenced to three months imprisonment on a suspended sentence, in addition to payment of £5,177 damages to the claimant and £17,000 in costs, for playing sound recordings in public without a licence in contempt of court.

Breach of jurisdiction clause – High Court protects company and affiliate by way of anti-suit injunction

A High Court decision highlights how Courts may construe parties' intentions when interpreting jurisdiction clauses in contracts, as well as the protection that can be afforded by way of anti-suit injunctions.Ben Clark explains the impact this will have.

Court rules are (not) made to be broken

The Andrew Mitchell "plebgate" defamation case in 2013 was well known for the political furore. Within legal circles, the case was a stark example of the court losing patience with people, and their lawyers, ignoring the rules.

The discount rate and professional negligence claims

When assessing damages in personal injury and clinical negligence claims future losses need to be taken into consideration. Our article explains how the discount rate works when making a claim.

Cosmetic Warriors and Lush Cosmetics – the construction of pre-emption rights

The recent decision in the case of Cosmetic Warriors Ltd & Anor v Gerrie [2017] EWCA Civ 324 dealt with the correct construction of shareholders' pre-emption rights.

PAG Management Services – abuse of insolvency law justified winding up in public interest

PAG Management Services Limited (“PAG”) were wound up under an application by the Secretary of State (“SoS”) in the case of PAG Management Services Limited [2015] EWHC 2404 (Ch) on the grounds of public interest.

A Football Club

We assisted a football club with the recovery of training compensation.