Lookalike IP disputes on the rise

2nd February 2022

In the recent issue of Ownership we looked at “the battle of the caterpillars” with M&S’ claim against Aldi for allegedly infringing various of its trade marks. Aldi fought back on social media, poking fun at M&S and gaining a lot of attention for the ‘plight of Cuthbert’ even going as far as showing Cuthbert in chains in their Christmas advert.

Not wanting to miss out on the festive fun, M&S brought a further claim against Aldi. This time alleging infringement of a design that the retailer had registered for its light-up, snow globe, gin bottle. Whilst similar bottles have been available for some time M&S allege that Aldi’s blackberry and clementine gin liqueur is “strikingly similar” to its registered design and “do not produce on the informed user a different overall impression to the [M&S] designs”.

In recent days it has been reported that Cuthbert has been freed and M&S and Aldi have settled their caterpillar dispute. We don’t yet (and probably never will) know the terms of the settlement but Aldi are understood to be releasing a new version of their Cuthbert cake in the near future.

Indeed, whilst M&S have frequently been the aggrieved party in such disputes, it has recently been reported that they are on the receiving end of a claim by French clothing brand Lacoste. Lacoste are famous for their crocodile logo and have, reportedly, brought a claim against M&S for infringement of their various trade marks as a result of M&S using depictions of crocodiles on various clothing and bedding.

We await, with interest, the outcome of the two remaining claims (and how Cuthbert looks when he is released). If you have any questions about copycat issues, or any of the other articles in Ownership, the please contact our expert intellectual property team for a ‘snappy’ response!


The Intellectual Property roundup from Blake Morgan

Read the magazine here

Enjoy That? You Might Like These:


8 November -
We will have all heard of artificial intelligence (AI) by now. But what actually *is* AI? And why is it unique from a legal perspective? In this article we delve... Read More


26 October -
In his Mansion House speech on 10 July 2023, the Chancellor Jeremy Hunt announced a package of long term reforms aimed at making the City of London a more competitive... Read More


28 September -
The implementation of the new FIFA Football Agent Regulations in England, which were due to come into force on Sunday, has been put on hold awaiting the outcome of a... Read More